When you purchase through tie-in on our internet site , we may earn an affiliate mission . Here ’s how it works .
An everlasting soul is a muscular conception ; it ’s the central feature of many organized religion and a deeply comforting opinion in the brass of loss .
Perhaps that ’s why some have been disgruntled with leave topic of the soul to faith , alternatively turning to science in attempt to prove the soul exists . If you ’ve ever heard that the soul weighs 21 grams — or seen the 2003 motion picture “ 21 gm ” alluding to this fact — you ’ve heard the termination of one of these rather strange experiments .
Legend has it that the soul weighs 21 grams.
So how much does the soul really weigh ? Well , the bad news program is that , of grade , no one can say . Science ca n’t shew that the soul exist , and scientist ca n’t weigh it . But the freaky write up of one doctor ’s attempt to do just that is deserving hang around for .
The account begin at the turn of the last century in Dorchester , a vicinity in Boston . A reputable physician call Duncan MacDougall had a bee in his cowling : If world had souls , he thought , those souls must take up space . And if person take up space , well , they must consider something — right ?
Weighing the soul
There was just one way to find out out , MacDougall reasoned . " Since … the substance turn over in our hypothesis is linked organically with the physical structure until death takes place , it appear to me more sensible to think that it must be some form of gravitative matter , and therefore open of being find at death by librate a human being in the act of dying , " hewrote in the scientific paper he would finally publishin 1907 about this effort .
MacDougall team up up with Dorchester ’s Consumptives ' Home , a charitable hospital for late - stagetuberculosis , which at that time was incurable . MacDougall built a prominent scale , adequate to of holding a cot and a dying tuberculosis patient . Tuberculosis was a commodious disease for this experimentation , MacDougall explained in his paper , because patients died in " great exhaustion " and without any bm that would jiggle his graduated table .
MacDougall ’s first patient , a man , died on April 10 , 1901 , with a sudden driblet in the scurf of 0.75 oz. ( 21.2 grams ) . And in that consequence , the legend was deport . It did n’t matter much that MacDougall ’s next patient lost 0.5 ounce ( 14 grams)15 minutesafter he stopped breathing , or that his third case showed an inexplicable two - step loss of 0.5 ounce and then 1 Panthera uncia ( 28.3 g ) a instant later .
Legend has it that the soul weighs 21 grams.
MacDougall threw out Case 4 , a woman dying of diabetes , because the scale was n’t well calibrate , in part due to a " good spate of interference by the great unwashed opposed to our work , " which raises a few questions that MacDougall did not seem eager to do in his write - up . event 5 lose 0.375 ounce ( 10.6 grams ) , but the scale malfunctioned afterward , upraise questions about those numbers , too . Case 6 got give out because the patient give way while MacDougall was still adjust his shell .
MacDougall then repeated the experiment on 15 cad and found no red of weight — signal , to his mind , that all click unquestionably do not go to heaven .
MacDougall reported his results in 1907 in the diary American Medicine and the Journal of the American Society for Psychical Research . He also snagged a write - up inThe New York Times .
Unanswerable questions
MacDougall ’s study had a minuscule sampling size , and his results were all over the topographic point , so even at the time , it cast the belief that he measure the soul into serious question . To MacDougall ’s reference , he take on that more measurements were needed to confirm that the person had weightiness . That has n’t happen — in part for ethical reason , and in part because the experiment are a bit … kooky . A rancher in Oregon did attempt to reduplicate the soul - weighing experiment with a XII sheep in other 2000 , agree to Mary Roach ’s book of account " weirdo : Science tackle the Afterlife " ( W. W. Norton & Co. , 2005 ) . Mostgainedbetween 1 and 7 ounce ( 30 to 200 grams ) , though the gains lasted just a few seconds before the sheep returned to their original weights .
— Can psyche prevail when they are rationalise off from the domain ?
— Why have n’t we cloned a human yet ?
— Does the human body really replace itself every 7 age ?
Roach also reported that Dr. Gerry Nahum , a chemical engineer and MD who was at the Duke University School of Medicine at the time , had developed a hypothesis that the soul , or at least the consciousness , must be link with information , which is equivalent to a certain amount of vigour . Because the equationE = mc ^2dictates that energy equals aggregative times the velocity of short squared ( thanks , Einstein ) , this energy could , essentially , be weighed with sensitive enough electromagnetic instruments . As of 2007 , Nahum had not get funding for experiment that would prove whether he was veracious . He now works for Bayer Pharmaceuticals . ( Roach indite that Nahum did not trust to pull a MacDougall and do his tests on humans . rather , he was considering bloodsucker as subjects . )
The bottom line is that skill has not remotely regulate the weight of the soul , nor whether the soul exists at all . Chances are , this interrogative sentence will be pull up stakes to the religious land .
Originally published on Live Science on Dec. 01 , 2012 , and rewritten on July 25 , 2022 .
